Section 8 Vouchers vs. Project-Based Section 8 Housing

Section 8 vouchers let eligible families rent from private landlords. Project-based Section 8 housing offers affordable rentals owned and administered by private or public groups. Both programs have eligibility conditions, waiting lists, and location-specific availability.

The purpose of this article is to provide a comprehensive overview of Section 8 vouchers and project-based Section 8 housing, including their eligibility requirements, application processes, benefits, and drawbacks.


Section 8 Vouchers

Section 8 helps low-income families pay rent. Local Public Housing Agencies (PHAs) nationally run the HUD-sponsored program. Private rental coupons are given to eligible households. The voucher covers the remaining rent up to a PHA limit. The program provides low-income families with affordable, safe housing. Voucher holders can move and choose where to live, promoting housing variety.

Eligibility Requirements

To be eligible for Section 8 vouchers, households must meet specific requirements established by HUD and local PHAs. These requirements include:

  1. Income eligibility: The household’s income must be below 50% of the area median income (AMI) for their geographic region. However, PHAs may adjust this income limit based on local housing market conditions and other factors.
  2. Citizenship or eligible immigrant status: Only U.S. citizens or eligible non-citizens are eligible to receive Section 8 vouchers.
  3. Criminal background checks: PHAs are required to conduct background checks on all adult members of the household. Applicants with a history of drug-related or violent criminal activity may be deemed ineligible for the program.
  4. Other requirements: PHAs may have additional requirements for eligibility, such as preferences for specific populations, such as veterans or the homeless.


Meeting these criteria does not ensure program acceptance. Many PHAs have Section 8 voucher waitlists due to the high demand for affordable housing. Funding and program involvement affect waiting list length.


Application Process

To apply for Section 8 vouchers, eligible households must contact their local PHA to submit an application. The application process typically involves the following steps:

  1. Contacting the PHA: Section 8 voucher applicants should contact their local PHA for information and an application.
  2. Application: Income, household composition, and other eligibility criteria must be documented. Applicants must provide income, assets, and spending for all household members.
  3. Submitting the application: The PHA accepts completed applications in person, by mail, or online.
  4. Waiting for eligibility determination: The PHA will analyze the application and do background checks. If eligible, applicants will be placed on a Section 8 voucher waiting list.
  5. Receiving a voucher: When a voucher is available, the PHA will contact the applicant to issue it and provide instructions.


Due to the strong demand for affordable housing and limited program financing, the application process can take months or years. Applicants should be patient and ready to give any additional information or documentation asked by the PHA during eligibility determination.


Benefits of the Program

Section 8 vouchers help low-income families find affordable housing. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development funds the program, which offers rental assistance to qualifying households. This article covers Section 8 voucher program eligibility, application, benefits, drawbacks, and successful implementation.

  1. Choice of housing: Section 8 voucher holders can reside anywhere as long as the rental unit fulfills health and safety criteria and the landlord participates in the program.
  2. Flexible payment options: Eligible households receive rental assistance to help pay rent. The household’s income and rental unit’s fair market rent determine assistance.
  3. Ability to move: Voucher holders can use their vouchers to rent a new unit if it fits program standards.
  4. Long-term stability: Eligible households receive ongoing rental support, which can help prevent homelessness.
  5. Rent support helps low-income households afford to house.
  6. Voucher holders may be able to afford better, healthier homes because the program requires rental units to fulfill health and safety criteria.


Overall, the Section 8 voucher program can help eligible households achieve greater housing stability, affordability, and quality of life.


Drawbacks of the Program

Despite its many benefits, the Section 8 voucher program also has some drawbacks that should be taken into consideration. Some of the main drawbacks include:

  1. Waiting lists: Due to high demand and limited financing, many PHAs have significant program waiting lists. This can hinder rental assistance for low-income households.
  2. Finding participating landlords: Voucher holders may have fewer housing options if some landlords don’t participate in the program.
  3. Rent restrictions: The scheme limits voucher unit rent, making it hard for landlords to cover their expenditures and limiting unit availability in some areas.
  4. Program funding: Congress’s annual appropriations can cause uncertainty and instability for PHAs and voucher holders.
  5. Voucher holders can pick where to reside, however, participating landlords and rental units may limit their options.


Despite these drawbacks, the Section 8 voucher program remains an important resource for low-income households in need of affordable housing.


Project-Based Section 8 Housing

Project-based The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) administers and provides funding for another affordable housing aid program known as Section 8 housing. Low-income families and individuals are eligible for rental assistance through this program, and property owners are required to set aside a specific number of units in their rental homes for these families and individuals.

Eligibility Requirements

Project-based Section 8 housing is limited to HUD-contracted homes. Thus, applicants must agree to live in a program-designated property. The property owner or local Public Housing Agency (PHA) managing the program may set eligibility conditions.

Homeless, substandard, and high-rent households may also receive preferences. Preference may be given to certain applicants. Income, household makeup, and other factors determine project-based Section 8 eligibility.

Application Process

Personal and professional references and a criminal history check may also be required. After receiving the application, the property owner or management business will assess if the household meets program eligibility requirements.

If approved, the household will be offered a rental unit in the HUD-project-based Section 8 property. Section 8 will provide rental support to the household. The program compensates for the difference between the household’s income and the rent.

Project-based Section 8 housing applications vary per property owner and local PHA. Some properties have waiting lists or preferences for selecting eligible households.


Benefits of the Program

Project-based Section 8 housing is an important affordable housing assistance program that provides eligible households with long-term stability and affordable rental housing. In this section, we’ll explore the benefits of the program.

  • Guaranteed affordable rent
  • Long-term stability in housing
  • Ability to live in high-quality rental units
  • On-site supportive services for eligible households
  • The incentive for property owners to maintain and improve rental properties
  • Ongoing rental assistance for eligible households


Overall, the benefits of project-based Section 8 housing are significant, providing a pathway to stable, affordable housing for many low-income households. These benefits can help promote long-term stability, improve well-being, and create a stronger sense of community for eligible households.


Drawbacks of the Program

Another potential drawback of project-based Section 8 housing is that property owners may not always maintain the units to the highest standards, leading to issues with maintenance and repairs. Additionally, households may face difficulties if they need to move before their lease is up, as they may lose their rental assistance. Finally, some households may find it difficult to meet the eligibility requirements for project-based Section 8 housing, particularly if they have unique circumstances that do not fit neatly into the program’s guidelines.


Comparison of Cost

Affordable housing programs such as Section 8 vouchers and project-based Section 8 housing are crucial in helping low-income households access safe and affordable housing. However, the costs associated with these programs can differ in significant ways. Here’s a comparison of the costs associated with Section 8 vouchers and project-based Section 8 housing.

Cost of Section 8 vouchers

The Section 8 voucher program is generally considered to be more cost-effective than project-based Section 8 housing. Here are some factors that contribute to the cost of Section 8 vouchers:

  1. Administrative costs: The administrative costs of Section 8 vouchers are typically lower compared to project-based Section 8 housing. This is because the voucher program is managed by the local Public Housing Agency (PHA), and the administrative costs are shared between the PHA and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).
  2. Cost to tenants: The cost to tenants in Section 8 vouchers are generally lower because the tenant pays a portion of their income towards rent, with the remainder covered by the voucher. The tenant’s portion is typically 30% of their income.
  3. Cost to landlords: Landlords participating in the Section 8 voucher program receive a portion of the rent from the tenant and the remainder from the PHA. However, some landlords may be hesitant to participate in the program due to concerns about the bureaucracy involved.


Overall, the Section 8 voucher program is considered to be a cost-effective way of providing affordable housing assistance to eligible households.


Cost of Project-Based Section 8 Housing

In addition to their differences in flexibility and stability, the Section 8 voucher program and project-based Section 8 housing also differ in terms of cost. In this section, we will compare the costs associated with both programs.

  1. Capital costs: The capital costs of project-based Section 8 housing can be higher compared to Section 8 vouchers because the property owner or developer must invest in constructing or renovating the rental units to meet HUD’s requirements.
  2. Operating costs: The operating costs of project-based Section 8 housing can be lower compared to Section 8 vouchers because the property owner receives a fixed rental income, with the rental assistance provided by HUD covering any difference between the tenant’s portion and the rent amount.


While both programs aim to provide affordable housing assistance, the costs associated with each program can vary significantly. By understanding the differences in cost, households and policymakers can make more informed decisions about which program may be the best fit for their needs.



Section 8 vouchers and project-based Section 8 housing help low-income Americans afford to house. Both programs have similarities, but their flexibility, stability, and cost vary. Affordable housing strategies should weigh each program’s pros and cons.

They should also examine their communities’ specific requirements before choosing a program. Section 8 vouchers and project-based Section 8 housing can be found on the HUD website. Online and print resources analyze these initiatives and their effects on low-income households.

Table of Contents