Comparing Section 8 Housing to Previous Housing Policies

Section 8 housing, also known as the Housing Choice Voucher program, differs from previous housing policies in several ways. First, it allows low-income families to choose their own housing, rather than being assigned to specific developments. Second, it provides rental assistance directly to the tenant, rather than to the landlord.

In this blog, we will provide an overview of Section 8 housing, its purpose, and how it compares to previous housing policies in the United States.


Section 8 Housing

Section 8, commonly known as the Housing Choice Voucher Program, is a federal program that helps low-income families, seniors, and disabled people pay rent. This program helps families find safe, decent, and inexpensive private rental homes. Section 8 housing requires an income of 50% or less of the regional median. Area and family size determine income constraints. A criminal background check and U.S. citizenship are also required.

Section 8 offers Project-Based Vouchers (PBVs) and Tenant-Based Vouchers (TBVs). A public housing agency (PHA) or private owner who contracts with a PHA to provide homes to eligible residents owns PBVs. However, TBVs are attached to the renter and can be used to rent any qualifying private rental unit that meets program conditions.

Section 8 housing helps eligible low-income families and individuals find safe, quality, and affordable housing. Eligible folks can choose the residence that best suits their needs through this program. Section 8 housing gives eligible individuals and families a safe and stable place to live, improving their well-being and quality of life.


Advantages of Section 8 Housing for Tenants

Section 8 housing is a critical program that provides affordable housing options for eligible low-income families and individuals in the United States. In this section, we’ll explore some of the key advantages of Section 8 housing for tenants.

Advantages of Section 8 housing for tenants


  1. Affordable Housing: Section 8 subsidizes rent for low-income families and individuals. Rent and utilities often account for 30% of tenants’ income.
  2. Access to Better Housing: Section 8 vouchers can be utilized to rent from any participating landlord, allowing tenants to live in neighborhoods with better schools, transit, and work possibilities.
  3. Stable Housing: Tenants have stable housing if they satisfy eligibility standards and follow program guidelines. Families with children and seniors who are more exposed to home insecurity benefit from this stability.
  4. Healthier Living Conditions: Section 8 housing must meet safety and sanitary standards to keep occupants healthier.
  5. Opportunities for Self-Sufficiency: Some Section 8 programs provide job training, education, and financial advice to help renters become self-sufficient. Tenants can become financially independent and less dependent on governmental aid.


Overall, the Section 8 program provides critical support to low-income families and individuals who may otherwise struggle to find affordable and safe housing. By providing financial assistance and support services, the program helps to improve the quality of life for its participants and enables them to achieve greater financial stability and self-sufficiency.


Previous Housing Policies

Previous housing policies in the United States aimed to address the housing needs of low-income households and improve living conditions for all citizens. Some of the key features and limitations of these policies include:

  • Public Housing: The New Deal built public housing in the 1930s. Low-income households lived in public housing. Public housing was neglected and had a bad image.
  • Urban Renewal: Urban renewal projects in the 1950s and 1960s cleaned up dilapidated neighborhoods and built new homes and businesses. Urban regeneration typically uprooted low-income residents and failed to fix urban degradation.
  • Rent Control: Rent control regulations limited landlords’ rent, making housing more accessible for low-income people. Rent restriction decreased housing investment and quality.
  • Subsidized Housing: The Housing Act of 1949 funded affordable housing construction and maintenance. These programs often had low financing and extended housing aid waitlists.


These policies paved the way for future housing policies and programs, such as Section 8, which aimed to address the shortcomings of previous policies and improve access to safe and affordable housing for low-income households.


Comparison of Section 8 to Previous Housing Policies

Affordable housing for low-income families and individuals has helped address the US housing issue. Section 8 differs from prior housing laws in goals, implementation, and impact. This section compares Section 8 to prior policies and discusses its pros and cons.


Previous housing policies had the goal of providing low-income families and people with access to inexpensive housing, with the government responsible for the construction and management of public housing units.

The goal of the Section 8 program is to ensure that households with qualifying low incomes have access to safe and affordable housing in the private market through the provision of rental assistance.



In previous housing policies, the government was responsible for the building and operation of public housing units. In contrast, Section 8 is administered through a voucher system. Rental assistance is provided to households that are eligible for the Section 8 program in order for those households to rent privately owned flats or homes from landlords who participate in the program.


Previous housing policies came under fire for being seen as contributing to the maintenance of segregation and the formation of pockets of concentrated poverty in some locations. On the other hand, the Section 8 program has been quite effective in its mission to assist millions of low-income households with their monthly rent payments, thereby giving these households access to a larger variety of housing options. On the other hand, the initiative has been criticized for not effectively addressing the housing crisis and for contributing to the continuation of segregation.


Current State of Section 8 Housing

Section 8 housing has changed, yet it still has major drawbacks. The Moving to Work (MTW) program’s expansion encourages creative housing solutions. In high-cost neighborhoods, higher Fair Market Rents (FMR) enable tenants to afford safe, adequate housing.

Lack of money causes extensive waiting lines and restricted housing assistance for Section 8. The initiative has been criticized for reinforcing segregation and not addressing the housing crisis. The program’s paperwork and inspections may deter landlords from accepting Section 8 vouchers.

Improvements have been suggested to solve these issues. enhance program financing to shorten waiting lists and enhance rental assistance. Streamlining the registration and inspection process would make it easier for landlords to participate and increase the number of Section 8 rental units. Incentives for landlords to accept Section 8 vouchers in better opportunity locations could further increase housing choices for low-income families.



In conclusion, housing policies have a significant impact on the lives of individuals and families, particularly those with low incomes or facing other forms of marginalization. Section 8 housing has been a crucial program in addressing housing needs, but it faces significant challenges and limitations.

Addressing these issues and promoting greater equity and access to safe and affordable housing should be a priority for policymakers, housing advocates, and community members alike. By working together to address these issues, we can help to ensure that everyone has access to safe and decent housing, regardless of their income or background.

Table of Contents