11 Common Reasons for Lawsuits Between Landlord and Tenant

Disputes between landlords and tenants are not uncommon, and can often lead to legal action. Common reasons for such lawsuits include failure to pay rent, property damage, eviction proceedings, and lease violations. To avoid such problems, both parties must grasp their legal rights and responsibilities.

In this article, we’ll explore 11 common reasons for lawsuits between landlords and tenants, and provide insights on how to prevent and manage such disputes.


1. Failure to Pay Rent

Non-payment of rent can have serious consequences for both parties. Tenants risk losing their housing and damaging their credit rating, while landlords face financial losses and potential property damage caused by a tenant’s eviction.

Tenants may struggle to pay rent under numerous conditions. Job loss, medical emergencies, and financial difficulties are examples. Tenants may withhold rent if they believe the landlord is not meeting their contract duties over property maintenance.

Tenants should freely discuss financial issues with their landlords to avoid legal action for non-payment of rent. Landlords can help tenants set up payment plans or extend payment deadlines. Mediation or arbitration may resolve payment problems without court intervention.


2. Property Damage

Common types of property damage caused by tenants include holes in walls, stained carpets, and broken appliances. In severe cases, tenants may cause structural damage to the property, such as damage to plumbing or electrical systems.

Landlords must prove damage and cost to claim repairs and cleaning. They may deduct repairs from the tenant’s security deposit but must follow state security deposit requirements. Tenants can dispute unwarranted claims by proving the damage was pre-existing or caused by regular wear and tear.

To avoid legal action over property damage, landlords should conduct regular inspections of their properties to identify any damage early on. Tenants should report any damage to the landlord as soon as possible to ensure prompt repairs and to avoid any liability for damage that worsens over time.


3. Breach of Lease Agreement

A breach of the lease agreement can also lead to legal action between landlords and tenants. When either party fails to fulfill their obligations under the lease agreement, legal action may be taken to seek compensation or eviction.

Common lease violations by tenants include subletting, having unauthorized pets, and engaging in illegal activities on the rental property. Landlords may also breach the lease agreement by failing to maintain the property or provide necessary repairs in a timely manner.

Landlords can pursue eviction or financial restitution for lease breach damages under state and local legislation. Tenants can defend themselves against false claims by proving they did not violate the lease agreement or fixing the violation immediately.


4. Lease Termination Disputes

Disagreements over lease termination can also lead to legal action between landlords and tenants. When either party wishes to end the lease agreement before its expiration, legal disputes may arise.

Landlords may seek to evict tenants who violate the terms of the lease agreement, such as by failing to pay rent or causing property damage. Tenants may seek to break the lease early due to unforeseen circumstances, such as job loss, relocation, or changes in property ownership.

In cases of lease termination disputes, landlords must follow state and local laws regarding eviction and lease termination. Tenants must provide proper notice of their intent to terminate the lease and may be held responsible for rent and other costs until the lease is terminated.


5. Security Deposit Disputes

Security deposit disputes are another common reason for legal action between landlords and tenants. Security deposits are typically held by landlords to cover unpaid rent or damages to the property.

Landlords may withhold part or all of the security deposit to cover damages or unpaid rent but must provide an itemized list of deductions and the remaining balance within a certain timeframe. Tenants can challenge unjustified deductions by providing evidence of the property’s condition before and after their tenancy.

Landlords and tenants should document property conditions before and after tenancy to avoid security deposit disputes. Landlords should also explain how to get a complete security deposit refund and return it within the permitted deadline. To understand security deposit obligations, tenants should read the lease.


6. Discrimination Claims

Discrimination claims are a serious legal issue that can arise in landlord-tenant relationships. Discrimination based on race, gender, religion, or other factors is illegal under the Fair Housing Act and can lead to legal action against landlords.

Examples of situations where discrimination claims may arise include unfair screening criteria, such as credit checks or background checks, that disproportionately affect certain groups of tenants. Landlords may also be accused of differential treatment of tenants based on their race, gender, or other protected factors.

Tenants can report discrimination to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development or a local fair housing organization. Discriminating landlords may suffer fines, penalties, and reputation damage.



7. Illegal Eviction

Illegal eviction is a serious legal issue that can lead to legal action by tenants. Landlords must follow proper procedures and obtain a court order before evicting a tenant. Failure to do so can result in a lawsuit and other legal consequences.

Examples of illegal eviction practices include changing locks, removing belongings, or shutting off utilities. These actions are considered “self-help” evictions and are prohibited under the law.

To avoid illegal eviction, landlords must follow proper procedures and provide tenants with notice before attempting to evict them. This includes providing written notice and obtaining a court order before initiating the eviction process. Tenants also have the right to a hearing to contest the eviction.

If a tenant believes they have been illegally evicted, they can file a complaint with the local housing authority or seek legal action against the landlord. Landlords who engage in illegal eviction practices may face serious legal consequences, including fines and penalties, as well as damage to their reputation.


8. Privacy Violations

Privacy violations by landlords are another common reason for legal action by tenants. Landlords have a legal obligation to respect tenants’ privacy and give notice before entering the property. Failure to do so can result in a lawsuit and other legal consequences.

Examples of privacy violations include entering without notice, installing surveillance cameras, or searching tenants’ belongings. These actions can be considered a breach of the lease agreement and a violation of the tenant’s rights.

Landlords must give 24-hour notice before entering the premises to avoid privacy infringement. Emergency repairs may require shorter notice. Landlords must also get approval before installing surveillance equipment and cannot inspect renters’ things without a warrant.


9. Verbal Agreements

Verbal agreements between landlords and tenants are another common reason for legal disputes. While oral agreements can be legally binding, they may be difficult to enforce or prove in court, leading to misunderstandings and conflicts.

Examples of verbal agreements include promises made by the landlord to make repairs or allow certain modifications to the property, or agreements made by the tenant to vacate the property by a certain date. Without a written record of the agreement, either party may dispute what was agreed upon.

Landlords and tenants should write agreements to avoid verbal agreements. Lease agreements, addendums, and changes to the initial agreement are included. Written agreements should explicitly state rent amounts, payment due dates, and property limits.


10. Violation of Housing Codes

Housing codes and regulations exist to ensure that rental properties meet certain minimum standards of safety, health, and habitability. Landlords are responsible for ensuring that their rental properties comply with these codes and providing tenants with a safe and healthy living environment. Failure to do so can result in legal action by tenants or local authorities.

Common housing code violations include lack of proper ventilation, heating or plumbing, pest infestations, electrical hazards, and structural problems. Other violations include the presence of lead-based paint, asbestos, or mold, which can pose serious health risks to tenants.

Housing code violators have various legal tools to sue their landlords. Local housing authorities may investigate and force landlords to make repairs after receiving complaints. Uninhabitable circumstances may allow tenants to withhold rent or cancel their contract.


11. Noise Complaints

Landlord-tenant lawsuits sometimes involve noise concerns. Noise is a normal aspect of apartment life, but excessive or disruptive noise can cause major issues between tenants. Landlords must ensure tenant peace.

Most rental agreements specify noise levels and timeframes. Disagreements over excessive noise may lead to noise complaints. Loud music, barking pets, and late-night parties cause noise complaints.

Landlords must address noise complaints. This may involve speaking to the offending renter, issuing warnings or fines, or even evicting tenants who repeatedly break noise regulations. If landlords ignore noise concerns or noise regulations, tenants may sue.



Finally, landlord-tenant lawsuits are expensive and stressful. Landlords and tenants can work together during the tenancy by identifying typical legal issues and how to avoid them. Landlords should prioritize safety, privacy, and eviction procedures.

Tenants must pay rent on time, report maintenance issues, and avoid property damage and disturbances. Landlords and renters can prevent lawsuits and have good tenancy by cooperating and obeying the rules.

Table of Contents